BBC and The Guardian battle it out in 2018 across UK Google News rankings
26. February 2019We’re taking the new year as a chance to look back at 2018 – and specifically how news websites performed in Google News and the search engine results pages in the UK.
All data is based on the Trisolute News Dashboard – a one-of-a-kind SEO tool that gives near-real-time data about rankings in Google News and the SERPs. To level the playing field and cover most general-interest news topics of 2018, we chose to base the analyses on our general keyword set. This set is based on Google News and Trends topics. We will cover the top 10 for the general News Boxes on desktop and mobile and top publishers for the different categories and will then move on to Google News. We will also add pictures for the most interesting results and add a special surprise at the end.
Desktop News Box Top 10: U.S. publisher joins pack
- bbc.co.uk – top month June, top keyword “scotland”
- theguardian.com – top month November, top keyword “brexit”
- express.co.uk – top month August, most top keywords were related to weather
- independent.co.uk – top month August, top keyword “apple”
- dailymail.co.uk – top month January, top keyword “celebrity big brother”
- thesun.co.uk – top month September, top keyword “apple”
- telegraph.co.uk – top month September, top keyword “jeremy corbyn”
- cnn.com – top month October, top keyword “donald trump”
- mirror.co.uk – top month January, top keyword “arsenal f.c.”
- sky.com – top month September, top keyword “corbyn”
The top keywords are spread out between country-wide news, technology and sports. Interestingly, few publishers share the month they registered their top visibility. Here we see cnn.com, which is the most visible publisher across all ranking types in the U.S., broaden its visibility into Google’s UK news-related rankings, but with a U.S. topic in their best month.
Desktop New Box – Business category
Desktop News Box – Entertainment category
- dailymail.co.uk
- thesun.co.uk
- bbc.co.uk
- express.co.uk
- theguardian.com
Desktop News Box – Headlines/Top Stories category
- bb.co.uk
- theguardian.com
- express.co.uk
- independent.co.uk
- cnn.com
Desktop News Box – Health category
- bbc.co.uk
- theguardian.com
- dailymail.co.uk
- independent.co.uk
- express.co.uk
Desktop News Box – Science category
- space.com
- bbc.co.uk
- express.co.uk
- theguardian.com
- independent.co.uk
Desktop News Box – Sports category
Desktop News Box – Technology category
- theverge.com
- gamespot.com
- forbes.com
- express.co.uk
- polygon.com
Desktop News Box – World category
Mobile News Box Top 10: BBC takes top spot
- bbc.co.uk – top month December, top keyword “brexit”
- theguardian.com – top month November, top keyword “brexit”
- express.co.uk – top month December, top keyword “samsung”
- dailymail.co.uk – top month January, top keyword “celebrity big brother”
- independent.co.uk – top month August, top keyword “brexit”
- thesun.co.uk – top month September, top keyword “apple”
- telegraph.co.uk – top month September, top keyword “corbyn”
- sky.com – top month September, top keyword “theresa may”
- mirror.co.uk – top month January, top keyword “celebrity big brother”
- cnn.com – top month October, top keyword “theresa may”
Brexit is obviously top of mind for many folks living in the UK, whichever way it turns out – and that is reflected in the top keywords here. In fact, “brexit” is the top keyword for theguardian.com in the mobile and desktop News Boxes.
Again, a fairly high number of entertainment and technology keywords for the Top 10 publishers. And that pesky U.S. publisher cnn.com makes yet another appearance.
Mobile News Box – Business category
Mobile News Box – Entertainment category
Mobile News Box – Health category
- bbc.co.uk
- theguardian.com
- independent.co.uk
- dailymail.co.uk
- telegraph.co.uk
Mobile News Box – Science category
Mobile News Box – Sports category
- bbc.co.uk
- theguardian.com
- skysports.com
- express.co.uk
- dailymail.co.uk
Mobile News Box – Technology category
Mobile News Box – World category
- theguardian.com
- bbc.co.uk
- cnn.com
- reuters.com
- independent.co.uk
Google News: Similar Top 10 to Desktop News Box
In May 2018, Google undertook a complete redesign of news.google.com, both in the front-end look and the back-end and algorithm. When you look at the visibility over 2018, you can clearly see that changes that happened started in May.
Unlike most other countries we considered in our year in review analyses, youtube.com did not become a part of the Google News Top 10 most visible publishers. This might indicate that Google is surfacing fewer videos in Google News UK.
- bbc.co.uk – 9.27 highest visibility percentage, 4.16 lowest visibility percentage
- theguardian.com – 12.27 highest visibility percentage, 6.67 lowest visibility percentage
- dailymail.co.uk – 6.77 highest visibility percentage, 3.53 lowest visibility percentage
- express.co.uk – 5.5 highest visibility percentage, 2.07 lowest visibility percentage
- mirror.co.uk – 5.71 highest visibility percentage, 3.02 lowest visibility percentage
- thesun.co.uk – 5.35 highest visibility percentage, 1.12 lowest visibility percentage
- telegraph.co.uk – 4.44 highest visibility percentage, 2.5 lowest visibility percentage
- independent.co.uk – 4.88 highest visibility percentage, 1.92 lowest visibility percentage
- sky.com – 4.13 highest visibility percentage, 0.85 lowest visibility percentage
- metro.co.uk – 4.43 highest visibility percentage, 0.36 lowest visibility percentage
Google News categories: Business, Headlines/Top Stories and UK
Bonus: AMP visibility
As mobile devices continue to draw a larger audience, publishers need to pay attention to Accelerated Mobile Pages, or AMP. Google has all but said it is AMP enabled for mobile ranking types, which are more user-friendly, but of course there are challenges as far as page layout and especially monetization. The graphic below shows the percentage of AMP rankings in the general Mobile News Boxes for 2018 of the top 20 most visible publishers.
The Top 20 publishers all have rankings over 50 percent, which shows a high rate of AMP uptake in UK news websites.
Conclusion
Unlike other countries, the Google News redesign did not result in youtube.com entering the Google News top rankings, though certainly there were other big changes.
Overall, two UK publishers – theguardian.com and bbc.co.uk – ruled most rankings and categories. There was an unusual number of technology and entertainment keywords as most visible for the publishers in the Top 10 lists for overall ranking types.
Lastly, the top publishers in mobile News Boxes have unusually high AMP rankings compared with the other countries (France, US, Australia, Germany, Switzerland) we’ve measured in these year in review analyses.
Methodology
We collect our news-related keywords from Google News (news.google.com) as well as Google Trends, and keywords are from Jan. 1-Dec. 31, 2018, for this analysis. News: Business, Entertainment, Health, UK, Science, Sports, Technology, Top Stories and World. 15 minutes rankings checks and on Google News every 30 minutes.
Read the full Year in Review 2018 analyses
Global Google News trends: What the most visible publishers in 6 countries reveal
10 most visible French publishers in 2018
The most visible Australian news websites in Google during 2018 – and their AMP percentages
What U.S. publisher dominated Google’s news rankings in 2018?
2018 im Rückblick – Welcher schweizer Publisher war am sichtbarsten?
Google News SEO – Deutschlands erfolgreichste Publisher 2018